A Conversation with David Dorn of Surf Club Maui
Q: How do you become a surf instructor on Maui?
Well, that’s a good question. A little bit depends on where you’re going to be teaching and who you’re going to be teaching. If somebody wants to, for example, become a surf instructor for us at Surf Club Maui, I can tell you how that goes. At Surf Club Maui, we train our instructors, but we cannot teach them how to surf. A surf instructor must already know how to surf because, when you teach a lesson, you have to know all of the factors that go into surfing. That includes understanding the waves, the ocean environment, and all of the struggles and experiences that come with learning how to surf.
A lot of the people applying to be surf instructors. For us, we prefer them to have not only years of surfing experience but a lot of local surfing experience. It’s not enough that they know how to surf. They have to know how to surf on Maui. They need to know the different breaks, the different seasons, and how the waves work here. It’s also helpful if they know the etiquette and customs at the different surf breaks. However, another thing too is that some people, including many of our instructors, have been born and raised right here in Kihei where we’ve surfed, and they have a lot of local knowledge, but they might be specialists and not have general knowledge. So it’s good to have a range of experiences that really help round a potential instructor out as a surfer. Now, a surf instructor doesn’t have to be a master of all things, but they have to have an appreciation and understanding of quite a range of things.
Q: So if someone already knows how to surf, what happens next? What are you actually looking for when you’re evaluating a potential surf instructor?
Well, there’s a little side note here too. As an instructor trainer, I’m also interested in whether somebody is self-taught or has learned from professional lessons. One of the most difficult hurdles for me when training a surf instructor is sharing with people that the way they learned is not necessarily the best way to learn, and it may be quite different from the way that we teach here on Maui. One of the next things that I look for in a surf instructor is whether they are open-minded. Some people get stuck in their ways because the way they learned worked for them and has been successful, so they ask, “Why change?” That is one of the most important traits for our instructors. They have to be open-minded enough that we can actually help them improve and adapt to our local techniques and methods. Open-mindedness and a willingness to learn new things are very important.
Q: What other qualities are important if someone wants to become a professional surf instructor?
Being a good surfer does not necessarily equal being a good instructor. Especially if the good surfer thinks that they are at the pinnacle of their sport and there’s nothing left to learn. They may be a competitive-level surfer or have surfed around the world, but that doesn’t necessarily give them the right attitude. The attitude is what’s important. Experience is great, but experience in big-wave surfing, for example, doesn’t necessarily give someone the tools they need to teach in small waves and crowded beginner breaks. Many of our instructors are high-level surfers, but they are also open-minded and can adapt to the teaching environment. The teaching environment is very different from free surfing on your own, competing, or surfing in big waves. They’re different ends of the same sport, if you like. Different areas of expertise and different skill sets. When you’re teaching, you’re not just managing yourself, your board, and the wave. You’re responsible for another human being, for their safety, and for their knowledge. What crosses over from being an advanced surfer is an awareness of risk. But the instructor has to be able to apply that awareness not just to themselves but to their students, especially if they have a class with multiple students. So it’s a different focus altogether.
Q: So how does someone make the transition from being a surfer to becoming a surf instructor?
Some people have taught a few friends and then get interested and think they might want to become a surf instructor. Some guys are surfers and simply want another source of income. Some people have already taught in other areas and want to teach locally. The transition for us is instructor training. That’s my role at Surf Club Maui.
Q: What does instructor training actually involve?
Our goal with instructor training is to take someone from wherever they are to the point where they’re able to take responsibility for a student and deliver our lesson program in a variety of conditions to a variety of students in a safe and consistent way. We have to train our instructors how to deliver a repeatable and effective lesson plan while also being able to apply it in a range of conditions. They must always be able to keep the environment safe and the students happy. In fact, the surfing instructor’s first job is safety. The second job is teaching students how to surf. That’s one of the first things we teach our instructors.
Q: Why do you put safety first?
That’s probably the most important thing to understand about a surf school, being a surf instructor, or water sports in general. You are putting somebody into a risky environment. The ocean is full of inherent risk. You don’t know if your student can swim, if they’re healthy, if they’re going to listen to you, or if they’ve ever been in the ocean before. Just putting them in the water is enough to put them at risk. As a professional school, you not only have to deliver the service, you have to bring the student back in one piece. It’s no joke. This is probably one of the most overlooked and underestimated roles of a surf instructor. They are a lifeguard first. It’s not enough to be trained in first aid, which our guys are. You have to be an accident avoider and risk mitigator. Surfing is an inherently dangerous sport. Going in the ocean is inherently dangerous. All ocean sports have inherent risk. Your job is to manage that risk. And that’s done before you even meet your students for the day. Risk management is a huge part of what we do. You’ve got to bring the student back in one piece. That’s the first law. In fact, you don’t put someone in the water unless you can reasonably expect that you can bring them back in one piece.
Q: What are some of the things instructors have to evaluate before a lesson even begins?
First, we have to teach instructors that they’re responsible for more than just the success of the lesson. The success is also the safety of the lesson, and that depends largely on the students’ needs and expectations. Every student is different. If someone is used to teaching friends, they may be used to teaching athletic people who already have some ocean sports experience. In a surf school, we have students ranging from six to sixty, and often much older than that. We see a range of fitness levels, ocean confidence levels, swimming abilities, medical conditions, and mobility levels. Some people are nervous. Some are confident. The instructor has to evaluate all of that. Sometimes they may even determine that a student is unteachable at that moment for a number of reasons. Sometimes the best thing they can do is not give the lesson. There’s a time to go and a time not to go. If the conditions are too extreme, inform the students, explain why, make it part of the teaching process, and invite them back on another day when conditions have improved. Instructors also have to evaluate ocean conditions, tides, waves, water quality, other water users, sea life, wind, rain squalls, and more. There’s a lot going on out there. It’s a very complex environment.
Instructor Training, Judgment, and Professional Standards
Q: It sounds like there’s a lot more going on than most people realize. How do you train instructors to manage all of those moving parts while they’re also trying to teach someone how to surf?
The training process shouldn’t be rushed. There’s a lot to learn, and we don’t expect a new instructor to be able to teach a group lesson on their first day. Usually, we start by giving instructors some of our online training tools to get them prepared. We have instructor training materials, lesson plans, videos, and an online training portal that introduces and explains many of the topics so instructors can arrive prepared. Then they come down and become passive assistants with our experienced instructors or instructor trainers, and they watch a number of surfing lessons to get used to the flow and sequence. Sometimes we’ll have a senior instructor with a helper who is observing and shadowing the lesson, and we try to have our instructors shadow in a range of lessons and a range of conditions. After that, they receive personal one-on-one training with me, and this is where we do simulated teaching scenarios, practice delivery of the lesson plan, and learn instructor skills and tips for dealing with specific situations and different types of students.
Q: So the training isn’t just about learning the lesson plan. It sounds like a lot of it is learning how to think like an instructor. What are you trying to teach during that shadowing and mentoring process?
The shadowing and mentoring process gives the new instructor an overview of a lesson, so they can see the flow from the beginning evaluation and meeting the student phase, flows to the gear selection, the setup, the land lesson. They’ve also shadowed the site assessment, the daily surf check with the senior instructor. They’ve met the students with the instructor, heard the instructor’s evaluation questions, and they’ve seen the gear selection and the timing and the moving to the land lesson, seeing the setup and how the land lesson is delivered, the pacing, the timing, and how they move from one phase of the lesson to the next, getting the students into the water, the timing, the on-water traffic, and the recovery back to the beach, and the breakdown process. The new instructor, the shadowing instructor trainee, is not expected to be able to deliver the program, but they assimilate the program so they get an understanding of the overall. Then, when we’re doing personal one-on-one training with these instructors, that’s where I come in and I’m delivering the detail on each section and discussing the challenges, the standards, and the different situations. Because a new instructor learns how to give the lesson, but they don’t know until they get experience if they should give the lesson. One of the hardest things for the new instructor is once they have had the training, is being able to say no, being able to call it. Because the instructor’s responsibility is not just delivering the quality lesson in a safe way, it’s being able to stop the lesson at any time if the conditions change and they can no longer maintain safety. And this requires a lot of confidence in themselves. My job as their trainer is to see how quickly and evaluate how well they’re assimilating the program, adapting and learning, and where their confidence level comes up, and if they’re using good judgment. And they may continue to shadow, or they might be allowed to teach a few easy students alongside our more experienced instructors. So they will have the other instructors around to guide them and keep an eye on them. We give them the easy students first, the easy in easy conditions, and that way they can get into the rhythm, practice delivering the program, and eventually, they will learn how to apply that same program in a widening range of conditions. Then they have to learn when to stop the lesson, and that’s where having the more senior guys and experienced instructors around helps because conditions can change while you’re in the water and you need to be able to see that happening in real time and stop lessons before they get dangerous. And there’s a number of reasons to stop a lesson in the middle, and not all of them are to do with you or to do with the weather, but it’s whenever safety is potentially compromised. Generally, that’s the reason to stop the lesson.
Q: It sounds like judgment is one of the hardest things to teach. At what point do you know an instructor is ready to teach independently?
Well, it depends on the individual instructor. They have to have experience, good judgment, humility, and they need to be able to follow the school’s teaching program. And that’s one thing where we’re very specific on the way we teach. Our teaching program has been developed over many years, not because it’s the easiest or the fastest, but because it’s the safest and most reliable way to teach and the most reliable way to learn. Our methodology has also been designed to minimize risk and reduce accidents during lessons. And this is something that someone inside of a lesson or a first-time potential instructor may not understand, that being a professional surfing instructor is different to teaching your friends. A professional instructor, which is what you are the moment you start getting paid or working for a school, you have to have professional standards, and that means having accountability and consistency. You can’t be giving a good lesson one day and then bailing out on your students halfway through the lesson on the next because the surf came up and you wanted to go surfing. You need to be there motivated to deliver the service to the student and guarantee a minimum level of safety. And you need to do that on a consistent basis, day in and day out. So it’s a tough job. It’s not for everybody. If you’re casual and you think it’s fun to do once or twice, but your mind is not on the job, your heart’s not in it, you won’t last very long. So somebody who comes in to be, who wants to surf every time the surf is good and is easily distracted will not be a probably good surf instructor candidate. But somebody who’s willing to put in the time, show up on time, and is motivated to deliver a quality service to the students, those are the ones that ultimately succeed. It also helps to be a people person, but some of our instructors are more reserved or on the shy side, and that’s okay as long as they can deliver the lesson properly and they have the necessary communication skills to do that part. They are probably gonna be good at their job. We’re not trying to be friends with the students. We’re friendly, but sometimes to be a professional instructor, you have to say no to your students. So many of our students become friends and lifelong customers, but we always have to remain professional, know our limits, know their limits, and keep it safe. So sometimes the hardest part of being a surf instructor is saying no and knowing when to stop a lesson. I’d say that’s one of the hardest things, because especially a new instructor might see stopping a lesson or saying no to a student is some sort of a failure, but it’s not, it’s discretion and judgment. And as a school owner, that’s more important than trying to make it work for everybody, regardless of the conditions, because that’s how accidents happen.
Q: How do you maintain instructor quality and consistency across the team?
The instructor’s quality control is helped a lot because we have an online training portal called OceanTrainer.org, which is where water sports instructors can go and get online training in a variety of topics, including weather, equipment, safety, as well as all of the specific instructor level training and theory for their sport. Surfing instructors also have the option, opportunity to cross-train on some other topics like stand-up paddleboarding, for example, and so they can broaden their skill sets. The online training portal is a great way for them to receive the core information, the updated information, and ensure that their understanding meets all of the standards and that they have the information that they need. The training portal is good because the instructor can do it outside of normal teaching hours. They can do it in a comfortable environment. It’s something they can access at home on their computer or even on their phone as a refresher. So it’s a resource that is accessible from anywhere and at any time, and it also is regularly updated, so always the latest versions of the training protocols are on there. There’s also so much background information that even an experienced instructor may or may not know about. So it really helps them get a deeper understanding in all of the aspects of surfing and the role of the instructor.
Q: If somebody is thinking about becoming a surf instructor, what’s the one piece of advice you would give them?
I would say speak to other surfing instructors and find out what the job really entails, what it looks like, what are the hours like, and physically, what’s involved. Because I think a lot of people are surprised how physically demanding it can be. It looks easy, but there’s a lot going on. Also, surfing instructors have to get up early, but so do surfers. So that’s part of the job. And also, they have to be consistent. To be a surfing instructor, you have to be reliable. So that would be my piece of advice. Talk to other professional instructors that do surf instructing as a full-time job and see if it’s really what you want to do. And then the second final piece of advice would be find a good school that has happy instructors and also offers in-house instructor training. Because if a school is willing to hire you to teach for them first day without any training, that’s probably not a good place to work.
Learn More
Interested in becoming a surf instructor or working in the ocean sports industry? The resources below provide additional information about instructor training, employment opportunities, and continuing education.
Join Our Team:
Learn more about employment opportunities, instructor expectations, and what it's like to work at Surf Club Maui:
Work With Us at Surf Club Maui
Instructor Training & Continuing Education:
OceanTrainer.org provides online training resources for water sports instructors, covering topics such as safety, weather, equipment, teaching methodology, risk management, and professional development:
OceanTrainer.org
Surf Club Academy:
Explore additional articles covering surf instruction, safety, technique, ocean awareness, and professional development for surfers and instructors alike:
Visit the Surf Club Academy